Lawyers and Settlements
Home Page >> News Articles >> It's Alive! Class Action Lawsuit against..

It's Alive! Class Action Lawsuit against Capital One Bank is Back On

. By

The Second Circuit reversed the lower court's dismissal of a customer's overdraft fee lawsuit against Capital One. The decision revives a class action lawsuit and a NY consumer law claim.

New York, NYTawanna Roberts's excessive bank overdraft fees lawsuit had all the familiar hallmarks. She claimed that she had a positive balance at the time she made the transactions that triggered the penalties, and that those penalties were made worse by Capital One's practice of reordering transactions to maximize what it could charge.

But for a while, it looked like all was lost. The District Court decided in May that the bank had that right to assess those fees. Then the Second Circuit Court of Appeals reversed breathing new life into Ms. Robert's case and the class action lawsuit that was building around it. This is good news, especially for plaintiffs who are not millionaires and who continue to get pummeled with excessive bank overdraft fees.

What does "pay" mean?

At the risk of disappearing down a legal rabbit hole, the lawsuit focuses on what the word "pay" means in Capital One's Deposit and Electronic Funds Agreements, to which Ms. Roberts agreed when she opened her checking account and applied for a debit card. More specifically, it was about whether "payment" occurred when the bank authorized the transaction (in which case Ms. Roberts wins) or when the bank actually settled with the merchant, which is later in which case the bank wins).

Anyone who has ever been puzzled about whether a checking account balance reflects some past, even long past, transaction can understand the problem.

Pouring salt in the wound, Capital One also appears to have reordered the sequence in which it cleared Ms. Robert's transactions to maximize the number of overdraft fees it charged, a practice lawyerly explained in footnote1 to the Second Circuit's opinion.

The District Court held for Capital One and tossed the lawsuit out. The Appeals Court was not so sure, and so permitted the lawsuit to continue.

Dig those bank agreements out of your bottom drawer

This would be a good idea for Capital One customers and also for other checking account customers, since Capital One's contractual language is probably not sui generis. The Second Circuit, which covers New York, Connecticut and Vermont, could be a very good place to file a lawsuit over excessive bank overdraft fees. If you can sue in New York, you may also be able to recover under New York consumer protection laws. It looks like bank customers may be back in the legal game when it comes to contesting overdraft charges.

Excecessive Overdraft Fee Legal Help

If you or a loved one have suffered losses in this case, please click the link below and your complaint will be sent to a consumer banking lawyer who may evaluate your Excecessive Overdraft Fee claim at no cost or obligation.
Request Legal Help Now


Posted by

I had a positive balance near the end of my time of using that capital one card and the next thing I knew, I had extra charge and then overdraft fees. I will never use that company ever again.

Posted by

I had it where they would tell if my bal was low by text and they wouldn' i owe then and its destroy Mr life can't get a bank account

Posted by

I had a Capital One account for a very long time until a few years ago when my husband passed away. I was not in good control of my finances then, but not, Capital One just really hit me with loads of late fees with very high interest which of course did not help my balance with them. Anyway, I finally had to pay a legal firm to help my debt be settled with them, as my income is basically Social Security benefits and I could not afford to pay their outrageous monthly payments with those high interest late fees. So basically, I ended up paying just to get out of debt with them. Then, they said I had not responded in time to receive a new card from the company. Mann, what a terrible thing.


Fields marked * are mandatory. Please read our comment guidelines before posting.


Note: Your name will be published with your comment.

*Email Address:

Your email will only be used if a response is needed.
*Your Comment:

Are you the defendant or a subject matter expert on this topic with an opposing viewpoint? We'd love to hear your comments here as well, or if you'd like to contact us for an interview please submit your details here.

Click to learn more about