Request Legal Help Now - Free


No Need to “Renew” Their Angst: Auto-Renewal Plaintiffs Remain Vigilant

. By
San Diego, CAPromoters of automatic renewals tout the convenience of ensuring continued service for busy consumers who otherwise might forget to renew a valued service on their own. Critics, however, counter that service providers are taking advantage of technology and online commerce to milk additional revenues from unsuspecting consumers. Little wonder many turn to an Auto-Renewal lawsuit.

That’s what one California resident has done after filing a proposed Automatic Renewal Program class action in November of last year. The unnamed plaintiff, who filed as “John Doe,” is litigating against NAC Marketing Company LLC and accuses the defendant of extending offers of continuous service or undertaking automatic renewals without obtaining explicit consent according to California law.

The state of California is one of a handful of states having put aggressive and specific laws on the books requiring marketers and service providers to ensure, beyond all reasonable doubt, that a consumer is aware and fully understands that to which he or she is agreeing.

NAC is identified as an online provider of subscriptions for service, marketing products purported to increase an individual’s libido and performance, promote muscle, increase energy and boost what is described as “free testosterone.”

The plaintiff, who filed his Auto-Renewal Subscription Program lawsuit in California November 9, accuses NAC of undertaking automatic renewal of a membership for service without affirmative consent.

According to court dockets, NAC moved to have the Automatic Renewal Program lawsuit dismissed - a motion that was eventually granted, with the barn left open for the plaintiff to refile. The plaintiff did so, submitting an amended complaint on January 21.

The automatic renewal phenomenon was born from the advent of the free trial offer, with a consumer required to contact the provider and subscribe in order to keep the service going. Service providers, some suggest, may have found that busy consumers either missed the renewal deadline for a service they valued, or were not translating into sufficient numbers of conversions from trial offers to clients without a “push.” That nudge became the automatic renewal based on information gleaned from enrollment in a trial offer that suddenly puts marketers and service providers in the drivers’ seat.

Consumers, as a result, have long complained that auto-renewal terms were not fully spelled out in agreements, were buried in fine print or omitted altogether.

The state of California amended the California Business and Professions Code, Section 17600, in 2010. Service providers must disclose the automatic-renewal terms in a clear and conspicuous manner before the agreement is completed, and that the terms must be in visual proximity to the consent for the agreement.

The aforementioned Auto-Renewal lawsuit is Doe v. NAC Marketing Company, LLC et al, Case Number 3:15-cv-02522, in US District Court, Southern District of California. Judge Anthony J. Battaglia presiding.


Auto-Renewal Program Legal Help

If you or a loved one have suffered losses in this case, please click the link below and your complaint will be sent to a consumer frauds lawyer who may evaluate your Auto-Renewal Program claim at no cost or obligation.


Posted by

Sign me onto 'Critics' list!
Add me to Critics List ASAP!
Now Network Marketing business opportunities like "TEAM NATIONAL" are starting to use such automatic billing tactics. Who knows, say there is no $ in bank account, right. And business failed or cannot/will not give you a specific date or date range that charge will hit your account for a draft, okay. POOF! KABOOM! Now you sit staring shocked to see a $38 overdraft for past 3 days (38x3)! (If you allowed bank to honor draft in 1st place.) I say this, NEVER ALLOW BANK to draft any charge on your account WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE funds to cover charge. YOUR BANK DOESN'T OFFER THAT? RUN to a new bank, run like your life depended on it! Get up & take care of your OWN business 1st!

Posted by

Finally! Finally consumers and states are addressing this horrendous and deliberate entrapment forced upon them by corporate greed-monger's. I, as one that has also felt the financially draining effects of this as well, only pray that this goes all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court which in turn will hopefully ban it's continued practice nationwide.

This matter is yet another debacle that should be eradicated from existence. And its users should be forced by Congress to reimburse every single defrauded consumer that has ever been swindled by automatic renewal practices.

Simply put it is ludicrous to allow such a practice to continue to proliferate! And I for one am extremely against its continuation. To the point that I, myself, just might take action against such.


Please read our comment guidelines before posting.

Note: Your name will be published with your comment.

Your email will only be used if a response is needed.

Are you the defendant or a subject matter expert on this topic with an opposing viewpoint? We'd love to hear your comments here as well, or if you'd like to contact us for an interview please submit your details here.

Click to learn more about

Request Legal Help Now! - Free