Request Legal Help Now - Free


$5.5 million Verdict Sets Transvaginal Mesh Lawsuit Precedent

. By
Bakersfield, CAA woman who suffered irreversible injuries caused by transvaginal mesh has been awarded $5.5 million by a California jury in the first major transvaginal mesh lawsuit. Transvaginal mesh attorneys say that this verdict sets a precedent for thousands of women who have suffered complications from the mesh device and have subsequently filed TVM lawsuits against a number of the TVM manufacturers.

Christine Scott’s case involved C.R. Bard’s Avaulta mesh, one of several transvaginal mesh manufacturers. Not only did the jury find the medical device company responsible for her irreversible injuries; the lawsuit also alleged that the TVM ruined the couple’s love life and the jury agreed, awarding the woman’s husband $500,000. The jury found that Bard was negligent in their handling of the devices, used to treat pelvic organs prolapse (POP), and stress urinary incontinence (SUI), according to Elaine Houghton, the plaintiffs attorney.

Christine Scott, age 53, is one of the worst cases. In 2008 she had the device implanted twice to treat occasional urinary incontinence. According to Houghton, the medical device began to cut her colon and she had tissue grow through the tiny holes in the mesh. Complications from the TVM resulted in eight separate surgeries and she might have to undergo further surgeries.

After a year of suffering, the couple filed a lawsuit against Bard and its Avaulta Plus transvaginal mesh device in 2009.

In an interview with KGET-TV 17 in Bakersfield, attorney Houghton said that the TVM product was tested on “16 rats, 12 rabbits, four sheep and, by their own researcher’s admission, the next living being this product went into was women.”

“Thank you, God. We can finally get the word out to women,” said Christine, in response to the verdict.

Attorney Holly Ennis believes this verdict will set a precedent for upcoming cases. “This verdict gives validity and merit to women’s transvaginal mesh claims and illustrates the gravity of some of the injuries sustained,” said Ennis.

So many federal lawsuits have been filed against transvaginal mesh manufacturers that five—and possibly more-- multidistrict litigations (MDL) have been filed to streamline the process. They include C.R. Bard (MDL 2187), American Medical Systems (MDL 2325), Johnson & Johnson’s Ethicon (MDL 2327 ) and Boston Scientific (MDL 2326).

The case is Scott v. Kannappan, S-1500-CV-266034-WDE, Superior Court for Kern County, California (Bakersfield). The first federal case (bellwether trial) is scheduled for February 5, 2013.

Despite hundreds, possibly thousands, of complaints and reports to the FDA, and more than 250 lawsuits over C.R. Bard vaginal mesh filed in federal courts throughout the US, the medical device company continued to keep its Avaulta products-- including the Avaulta Biosynthetic, Avaulta Plus and Avaulta Solo devices—on the market until they pulled it from the shelves in the US at the beginning of July 2012. The products were pulled only when the FDA asked for more clinical trials to determine their safety.
Incredibly, Bard is still selling its Avaulta line in other countries.


Transvaginal Mesh Legal Help

If you or a loved one have suffered losses in this case, please click the link below and your complaint will be sent to a drugs & medical lawyer who may evaluate your Transvaginal Mesh claim at no cost or obligation.


Posted by

I have spoke to many women who have had there mesh removed by Dr Miklos and most have had wonderful results. Dr Miklos will tell you the sooner you get the mesh out, the better chance of a better result. Check out his website

Posted by

Hi Rebekah try Dr Shlomo Raz at Clark Unrology at UCLA he is one of the best of the best and Dr Miklos. He's staff knows the in's and out's of this mesh condition.

Posted by

I had surgery done to remove extensive adhesions. During this surgery mesh was wrapped around intestines and organs to prevent the further development of adhesions. I have had no life since. The pain continues to get worse and I have no idea what is going on in there as I have been unable to find a doctor to deal with it or remove it. Where do these people find a doctor? At the present time I am unable to work or have a normal life due to the pain.


Fields marked * are mandatory. Please read our comment guidelines before posting.


Note: Your name will be published with your comment.

*Email Address:

Your email will only be used if a response is needed.
*Your Comment:

Are you the defendant or a subject matter expert on this topic with an opposing viewpoint? We'd love to hear your comments here as well, or if you'd like to contact us for an interview please submit your details here.

Click to learn more about

Request Legal Help Now! - Free