Request Legal Help Now - Free


Knee Replacement Recipient is “Done with Surgeries”

. By

Knee replacement recipient says she was better off before surgery. As well, Sandra recently survived breast cancer, but survivors shouldn’t deal with a defective knee.

Tampa, FLThe pain started right after Sandra had a Smith & Nephew knee replacement. “It never functioned properly and I never did get back a full range of motion like I was told,” says Sandra. “I had this metal-on-metal knee implant because my knee was bone-on-bone. This knee implant was supposed to make me better, not worse.”

Sandra had the surgery when she was 50 years old, which is quite young for a knee replacement. She worked for a package delivery service that involved a lot of stairs and heavy lifting. Over the years, wear and tear took its toll.

“My orthopedic surgeon said I would gain more range of motion when I went back to work. He is partly correct, but it was never what it should be,” Sandra says. “This Smith & Nephew knee was always loose, to the point that I fell down in the kitchen and broke my femur…”

That was three years ago. Breaking her leg was a nightmare because Sandra couldn’t move her knee. “I had a rod in my leg and that took two months to heel. Consequently, my knee was frozen so I was back in surgery so I could get some range of motion to walk,” Sandra explains. “And knee surgery is so painful. They operated three times when I broke my femur because I have prolific scar tissue, which is due to my knee implant.”

Sandra endured six months of physical therapy, three days a week. She had to live with her mother for three months—she was in her late 70s-- because her house is wheelchair friendly. “I could sit in the shower, the toilets are high enough, and no stairs to climb,” she says. “I was in a wheelchair and then a walker for two months. And to top it all, I got an infection from the hospital during one of the surgeries…”

Actually, the infection was the penultimate. Sandra was going to have revision surgery but to really top things off, she was diagnosed with breast cancer (she is now cancer-free). Needless to say, she is done with hospitals and surgery.

Sandra had to retire from her job. Fortunately, she was able to collect long-term disability insurance right away.

“ I don’t know if this knee implant is the wrong model for me or if it is defective. This company has been making knees for years, but I do know that this model was new to the market,” Sandra says. “I did some research and discovered that this company has issued some recalls, so they don’t have a good track record.”

In early 2010, about 40,000 Smith & Nephew Uni Tibial Baseplate knee implants were recalled after complaints of the base plate breaking. A broken base plate could lead to instability and premature wear of the knee replacement, often requiring additional surgery to revise the knee replacement or change the base plate.

One year later, at the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons annual meeting, a study was presented that found that 16 percent of the Smith & Nephew Journey-Deuce knee implants began failing after just 21 months, and 39 percent of those who received the implants reported poor results. In November of 2015 a recall was issued by the FDA; this time Smith & Nephew’s Genesis knee implant had a defective process design.

Sandra plans on getting the make and model number from her surgeon or the hospital, and if they aren’t forthcoming, an attorney can help. “My surgeon only told me the company name when I saw him before the surgery,” she adds. “The last time I saw him he thought the knee was a little bit loose and he could make the corrections with surgery, but they always say that. He never discussed why it is loose. And I am done with surgeries.

Now I have back problems, but I did maintain my weight. I go to the gym and walk a lot. A stationary bike gets my heart rate up, and it’s good for my back and knee. So, I’m managing but this knee was supposed to have made me better. And it wasn’t supposed to hurt all the time—that’s the reason I had the surgery in the first place. Looking back, I would be better off without a knee replacement.

I am frustrated and pissed off, it shouldn’t have happened this way. I am pissed off with the company and my surgeon who should have been more attentive because I should have had a total knee revision surgery before I broke my leg and before I was diagnosed with breast cancer. I was hoping for a favorable outcome, but hey, I’m a survivor.”

Sure, Sandra survived breast cancer. But survivors didn’t ask for a defective knee.


Defective Knee Implant Legal Help

If you or a loved one have suffered losses in this case, please click the link below and your complaint will be sent to a drugs & medical lawyer who may evaluate your Defective Knee Implant claim at no cost or obligation.


Posted by

I am a bit confused on this matter as I had a knee replacement, an Attune FDA approved device was used. Do to the immediate complications that still exists today, my doctor and a second opinioned doctor felt it best I wait until the two-year mark to revisit things. In the meantime, I continue to have mirror symptoms of the complaints mentioned by others and more, but the suggestion is that I wait till May of this year which will bring me to the two-year mark. I spoke with an attorney and was told that since the device in my knee was approved by the FDA, this has created some form of protection for Attune, thus any attempts of a lawsuit would more than likely be denied in court.

Can someone help me understand this, or concur with what I am being told medically, and judicially?


Please read our comment guidelines before posting.

Note: Your name will be published with your comment.

Your email will only be used if a response is needed.

Are you the defendant or a subject matter expert on this topic with an opposing viewpoint? We'd love to hear your comments here as well, or if you'd like to contact us for an interview please submit your details here.

Click to learn more about

Request Legal Help Now! - Free