Request Legal Help Now - Free


Nutella Has Been Served—with a Lawsuit

. By
San Diego, CA: Nutella, the hazelnut and chocolate spread created by an Italian company and marketed to North Americans, is the target of a consumer fraud lawsuit ignited by a Mom from California after she began to doubt its claims as a healthy and nutritious food. According to the statement of claim, Athena Hohenberg was shocked to hear that Nutella was, in fact, little different than feeding candy to her four-year-old.

"Just look at their website," says Ron Marron, a San Diego lawyer representing Hohenberg and other class members, "they make outrageous claims."

"It is false advertising and an unfair business practice," says Marron. "They are advertising this as healthy, and Nutella knows it isn't."

"Nutella has marketed itself as 'Europe's peanut butter' made from hazelnuts and a little bit of dark chocolate." However, Marron says, nothing could be further from the truth.

In the statement of claim, the suit alleges that Nutella contains over "55 percent processed sugar and dangerous levels of saturated fat."

Nutella is manufactured in the US by Ferrerro USA, a subsidiary of the Italian company Ferrerro International. A Nutella spokesperson recently told The Wall Street Journal that it "stands behind the quality and ingredients of Nutella and the advertising of its product."

Marron believes that the discovery process will reveal internal communications that show a company anxious to market its hazelnut and chocolate spread to children in North America, and anxious to convince parents Nutella can be part of a "balanced diet."

"I don't like the way they market this product to kids," says Marron, from the Law Offices of Ron Marron. "The company says this stuff is healthy, but it just isn't."

"And when you are a foreign corporation and you come into a country and use a different formula to manufacture your product, I think that is a problem," says Marron. "I think that the science will show us that the formula in North America is less wholesome here than it is even in Italy and Europe."

"Nutella doesn't abide by our advertising laws and markets the stuff to kids and parents as nutritious. I think that is a problem too," he adds.

The suit asks the court to force Nutella to discontinue marketing itself as a healthy food and asks that everyone who purchased Nutella be reimbursed for the cost of the product.

That could be millions of Americans, many of whom bought the product multiple times. "Yes, that's true," says Marron. "But I think anyone who bought this product with a false label on it should be able to get their money back."

Ron Marron is a veteran attorney who won a number of significant verdicts and settlements for clients. He is currently litigating a class-action consumer lawsuit against Quaker Oats for its nutritional claims. Marron has expertise as a securities and investments attorney, and has successfully represented clients in disputes over variable annuities, medical insurance, broker misrepresentation and negligence, and other related financial issues.

READ MORE ABOUT Consumer Fraud

Legal Help

If you or a loved one have suffered losses in a similar case, please click the link below and your complaint will be sent to a consumer frauds lawyer who may evaluate your claim at no cost or obligation.


Posted by

Is the mom stupid seriously lol we all no its not healthy lol is she saying she doesn't feed orange juice or chocolate to her kid... Goodness me I LOVE NUTELLA... If u think its unhealthy DONT BLOODY BUY IT

Posted by

This lawsuit makes all the nutella consumers look like idiots. I have been eating this since 6 years old, even then I knew that a chocolate, sugary spread is not healthy.
C'Mon people! Don't be ridiculous!

Posted by

For the record, saturated fats are the best fats for you. If you don't take my word for it then read this book. It'll open your eyes.

The Fat Revolution by Christine Cronau.

Posted by

It is wrong to change the product and put out false advertising, but it is also the responsibility of the consumer to educate themselves on what they are putting in their body, turn the jar over and read the lable!!!! I love Nutella but knew that the commercial was a big fat lie saying it was healthy. So many people act like sheep and just brainlessly watch commercials and buy products without thinking. It's really stupid. No consumer should get their money back for buying it, it was their own choice to blindly buy this product.

Posted by

im so dissappointed !! because every day, every morning my 2 kids breakfast is nutella, i thought it is a healty food to my 2 kids !! that so unfair!!

Posted by

How could anyone think that chocolate is healthy? Because the advertisements did not state the sugar content? Neither do snickers bars. Do people assume those are healthy too? I've found no claims other than by customers that Nutella is healthy. Anyone that just arbitrarily decides that a food is healthy because the manufacturer doesn't make claims otherwise and eats "tons" of it based on nothing (come on its chocolate!) is just a moron. Look at the nutritional label. Should I sue Nike because I bought their shoes and did not get drafted to the NBA. They never said i would, but they may have alluded to it. If you think 100 calories per tablespoon is healthy that's your prerogative but don't get upset because you were to ignorant to turn a jar around and read the other side. Peoples idiocy amazes me.

Posted by

C'mon! What about common sense? What about reading the list of ingredients? The first one is coconut oil!

Posted by

D: I am soo sad! I loved this stuff and ate TONS of it! I thought it was healthy. :\

Posted by

I have purchased Nutella for a year thinking it was nutritious and a healthy choice. I am very angry over this issue and find it disgusting to make a false claim on a product. I have wasted much money .


Fields marked * are mandatory. Please read our comment guidelines before posting.


Note: Your name will be published with your comment.

*Email Address:

Your email will only be used if a response is needed.
*Your Comment:

Are you the defendant or a subject matter expert on this topic with an opposing viewpoint? We'd love to hear your comments here as well, or if you'd like to contact us for an interview please submit your details here.

Click to learn more about

Request Legal Help Now! - Free