Court of Public Opinion Archive

Cathy Cruz Marrero: Why’d Security Let Her in Mall to Begin With?

January 20th, 2011. By AbiK

Rhetorical question—but I’ve had enough of this media circus over the mishap fall-into-the-fountain moment of Cathy Cruz Marrero. So yes, I’m going to join right in.

From the video gone viral, Marrero is seen texting while exiting an anchor store in a Pennsylvania mall. She’s distracted, and falls into a fountain dead ahead of her. I didn’t count the seconds elapsed, but she gets out fairly quickly and walks away. It’s not like she was struggling too hard to get out—she even managed to snag her phone as she climbed out. No stooping over to rub her knees. No holding her head. No limping. Ok, maybe she was in shock and a tad bit embarrassed. But with the speed she was moving at, she kind of seemed…ok.

So she was caught on the security camera. And somehow the video clip got from mall security to the internet.

Should someone in security—assuming that’s how the video went public—be given a talking to? Yes. Should they even face possible termination (a report on wfmz.com says the security guard has already been canned)? Sure. For distributing the video. But a lawsuit? And one based on the fact that mall security did not come to Marrero’s aid? Seriously. And mind you, I count at least five or six other people on the video who were in striking distance of the fountain fall and could’ve taken notice or responded. They did not. Nice? No. Worthy of legal recourse? Uh, no.

Having said that, I’m predicting mall security will not come out of this one with a dismissal of charges.

Now, be that as it may,ABCnews reported earlier that Marrero had been charged in October, 2009 with allegedly using a co-worker’s credit cards to rack up charges to tune of $5,000 at such fine establishments as Zales and Target. Sentencing is expected at her next court appearance on April 21st (as reported in the Reading Eagle) and she’s looking at perhaps six months of house arrest and electronic monitoring.

It gets better. ABCnews goes on to share that, according to court documents, Marrero also has “Marrero has convictions for retail theft four times and one other theft in New York from 1997 to 1999 and retail theft in York County in 1999.”

And…

“She also received 12 months of probation after being convicted of a hit-and-run charge in Berks County in 2009.”

Let me get this straight. She been charged most recently with five felony counts, including theft by deception and receiving stolen property. She’s been convicted four times for retail theft. She’s been convicted of another theft. And she’s been convicted of a hit-and-run.

Now, I know it’s innocent until proven guilty–but she’s been proven guilty of various charges several times already. And now she’s playing for public sympathy and some sort of revenge tactic against mall security? This is not some innocent middle-aged woman who’s had a terrible little mishap. And, note, I haven’t even touched on the fact that she, herself, was responsible for texting and walking simultaneously thereby reaping the wet rewards.

Please, this one is just another frivolous lawsuit in which no injury was truly done. What—Marrero’s reputation’s been wrecked? I think a pretty good rap sheet already achieved that, no? A bit of embarrassment? Hell yeah—that’s what happens when you do something stupid. In public.

And so now it’s another lawsuit that will clog up the media and clog up the courts—just as Marrero is about to pass through them again—as a defendant.

Tags: Berkshire Mall, Cathy Cruz Marrero, Fairgrounds Square Mall, Mall Security, Reading PA, Security
Posted in Court of Public Opinion, lawsuits, Personal Injury | 65502 Comments »2011-01-20+23%3A03%3A42AbiK

Don’t Just Blame The Laptop Pilots

October 28th, 2009. By Hunter West

blowupdollpilot2 Dont Just Blame The Laptop Pilots So everybody is up in arms over the Northwest Airlines flight that overshot Minneapolis airport last week because the pilots were busy with their laptops. Monday night Jay Leno had a field day, suggesting that when two guys are bored, what do they do for fun? Bring out the laptops and surf for…well, you know what comes next.

The pilots are suspended, as they should be. The public is outraged, as it should be. The outcome could have been far, far worse.

But let’s look at it another way. There were some things that went right. There was no alcohol abuse. And the pilots weren’t tired. There was a 17-hour break for the two men between flights, which means they were well rested.

Too many pilots because of fatigue, or illness have made too many deadly errors.

So let’s be thankful for that.

True, we should not allow the focus to be removed from two experienced pilots who should have known better. The New York Times reported October 27th that there were 31,000 hours of flying time between the two men. That kind of lapse in judgment, by two experienced pilots with the lives of 144 people (not to mention flight crew) in their control cannot be discounted. The New York Times quoted Robert Mann Jr., a veteran industry analyst, as saying the actions of Captain Timothy B. Cheney and First Officer Richard I. Cole, were “inexcusable.” Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: Airplane, Delta, Northwest Airlines, Pilot Error
Posted in Airlines, Court of Public Opinion | 1700No Comments »Don%27t+Just+Blame+The+Laptop+Pilots2009-10-28+14%3A19%3A18Hunter+West

A Fair and Just Legal System Also Needs Moderation

October 9th, 2009. By Hunter West

coffeecuphot A Fair and Just Legal System Also Needs Moderation Important as it is for citizens to have legal recourse to sue in order to right a wrong, do you sometimes wonder if things are getting a bit out of hand?

Case in point: in 2002 a detective with the New York Police Department (NYPD) accidentally shot himself in the knees while sitting on a chair and trying to holster his revolver. The following year he retired on a three-quarters disability pension and is now employed as a court officer in South Carolina making $24,000 annually.

He also sued the City of New York and last November was awarded $4.5 million in damages by a jury.

For accidentally shooting himself in the knee. For that kind money maybe we should all do that.

Obviously, the former NYPD man found himself a talented lawyer who presumably argued that the revolver, issued by the department, was faulty. As the NYPD is an agent of the City, the Big Apple would be on the hook.

Keep in mind that if we are injured, or victimized in concert with a situation or event through no fault of our own, we should have the right to seek compensation.

Case in point: the scores of women who have unknowingly put themselves in harm’s way by simply subscribing to Yaz birth control. They believed Yaz (and Yasmin) to be a safe and effective oral contraceptive, only to find out the hard way about risks for life-threatening blood clots and thrombosis. Women—painfully young, healthy women—have died.

And then there are the thousands of California workers who are robbed of their right to claim, Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: California Overtime, lawsuits, New York, Yasmin, Yaz
Posted in Court of Public Opinion | 1552No Comments »2009-10-10+01%3A15%3A52Hunter+West

Should we all just get high on Marijuana…legally?

August 18th, 2009. By AbiK

Not long ago I had posted about the drug Reglan—the drug that has been associated with Tardive Dyskinesia—and the possibility of using marijuana for medicinal purposes to alleviate some of the symptoms of the disorder. There really isn’t much more than ancedotal evidence to support using marijuana for Tardive Dyskinesia–and regardless, as of late July there were only 13 states that have actually legalized the drug. joint Should we all just get high on Marijuana...legally?

Just today, as a follow up, I thought I’d check out Urtak.com—a collaborative surveying site—to see what the pulse is on whether folks think marijuana should indeed be legalized.

The Court of Public Opinion has spoken. Well, at least 276 members of the public have answered the question on marijuana legalization over at Urtak. And if you’ve been following the issue in the media, you may not be totally surprised by the results—it is a fairly polarizing issue.

The results… Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: Court of Public Opinion, Marijuana, Reglan, Tardive Dyskinesia
Posted in Court of Public Opinion, Drugs/Medical | 10433 Comments »2009-08-18+17%3A54%3A13AbiK